The average construction dispute in North America now runs $60.1 million, according to the latest CMAA report. That’s roughly triple where it sat before the pandemic. If you’re a business owner about to sign a construction contract, that number should get your attention, because the fights driving it rarely start with bad workmanship or bad weather.
They start with paperwork the parties signed and never read closely.
The Dispute Starts in the Document, Not on the Site
The single most common cause of large construction disputes isn’t a subcontractor walking off or a slab poured wrong. For the third year running, the top driver has been errors and omissions in the contract documents themselves, with parties failing to understand or comply with their own obligations sitting close behind, according to the same CMAA analysis.
Read that again. The document is the problem more often than the build is. A vague scope, a missing definition, a clause pulled from a prior project and never revised — that’s where the loss starts. The site is just where it becomes visible.
Payment Clauses Decide Who Absorbs the Loss
The clauses that turn small problems into large ones almost always involve money and timing. If you’re the owner, you want to know exactly when funds release, what triggers retainage, and what happens when your lender’s schedule and your builder’s schedule don’t line up. Payment terms in standard industry forms often conflict with loan documents, and that mismatch is where funding delays and finger-pointing begin.
Two payment clauses deserve special attention before you sign:
- Pay-if-paid. This makes the owner’s payment to the general contractor a condition precedent to the GC paying subcontractors. Some states enforce it as written; others void it as against public policy, so enforceability depends heavily on where the project sits.
- Retainage and milestone releases. The amount withheld, when it’s released, and what counts as substantial completion should be defined in numbers and dates, not adjectives. Ambiguity here is where projects stall near the finish line.
- Change order procedure. Every change needs a written scope, a price, a schedule impact, and signatures before the work happens. Verbal approvals are how a modest change balloons into a major claim.
What to Do Before You Sign
The fix isn’t to become a lawyer. It’s to treat the contract as a business document that priced risk, and to price it accurately before the ink dries. A few practical moves:
- Read the flow-down. If your contract incorporates other documents by reference, you’re bound by clauses you may not have seen. Ask for every referenced document and read it.
- Align payment with your lender. Have the same person review the construction contract and the loan agreement so retainage, draws, and lien waivers actually match.
- Nail down the schedule terms. Define substantial completion, excusable delay, and liquidated damages in specifics, not templates.
- Get a construction lawyer on the front end. Bringing in an experienced construction attorney to red-line the draft costs a fraction of what you’ll spend defending an ambiguous clause later.
Eight-figure disputes don’t drop out of the sky onto other people. They compound out of clauses nobody read carefully. Read them now, or pay for them later.

